Essays/Leadership

Hiring for how people think

Hiring buys how a person makes decisions, not a list of past jobs. Experience accumulates fast; the way someone reasons through a new situation does not.

When I hire, I am not buying experience. I am buying the way a person makes decisions, which comes from the principles they reason with and which I call their thinking algorithm. A résumé records what someone has done and says little about how they will decide in a situation my business has not seen before.

Experience is not expertise

Business is decisions, in every moment. Experience is overrated today because it can be accumulated quickly: computers do nearly everything, and things change fast. Expertise is different. A researcher, a mathematician, a chess player or a nuclear physicist builds it over twenty years, and nobody picks it up in a month. Experience is decisive only when it is in fact expertise.

Ten years in marketing can be two different things. It can be ten years of accumulating principles of operation, patterns in how people and markets behave, which transfer to any new technology. Or it can be ten years of memorizing tactics that worked in a world that no longer exists. The first is valuable. The second is a liability, because the person will apply dead tactics to a live market with confidence. The résumé looks the same in both cases.

The reverse also holds. Someone who has been through only two formative events, and understood them deeply, can decide as well as someone with ten years understood shallowly. Some of these algorithms are formed by good experiences and some by painful ones. What counts is the algorithm.

What should an interview test?

How the person builds an answer when they do not know one. There is little point in walking through the résumé. The useful exercise is to hand them a situation they have not seen and watch them reason toward a decision. I look at whether they gather the right information, whether they find the essence or get lost in surface detail, and whether they update when a new fact is added or defend their first instinct.

One more thing shows in that conversation: what a person does at the edge of their knowledge. Two people can be equally ignorant of a new tool. One says teach me. The other says it worked fine the old way. The difference is the principle underneath, and the second person will resist at every technological turn. Pressure can sometimes shift a principle, but leading a company by force is exhausting and brittle. I would rather select for the disposition than spend my life supplying it.

Who do the first hires bring in?

People like themselves, not like the founder. Even when they are trying to serve what the founder wants, they filter candidates through their own principles. This compounds. Within a year the culture is the culture of whoever was allowed to hire, repeated a few times, and a values statement on the wall does not fix it later. So I think the founder should be directly in the hiring decision for at least the first few dozen people.

That is why the first hires should be chosen on values and principles: shared ones, or close enough to be understood and to trust the decisions they lead to. It is also why I would not keep a talented person whose behavior is toxic. The skill helps the tasks that person touches. The toxicity reaches everyone, and in a small company there is nowhere for it to dilute.

One warning. Sometimes we are not looking for values at all. We are looking for justifications of old wounds, reflected onto the partners and collaborators we choose. The self we hire from is not always the self that makes the best decisions.

A person’s time in a company is a cycle

I once told someone about results we had achieved with fewer than ten people, and added that I had no experience of running a large team. He was a successful man himself, and he asked why I thought success in business meant leading a large team. It does not. A small team is often the more efficient one.

In my experience a team moves in cycles. The first few people hired bring the company’s next cycle of success. Once the company gets there, most of those same people cannot understand the cycle after it, because the mind attaches to what worked.

That is not a moral failing. People generally stay until they have learned what they came to learn. Their growth is their own path and no judgment on the business. A small team may at some point need a shock to become a larger one, and sometimes that means replacing people, with fair compensation for everything they achieved up to that moment.

This can read as cold. I think it is the opposite. A founder who believes good people should stay forever feels every departure as a betrayal and handles it with resentment. Understanding that a person’s time in a company has a term is what makes it possible to part with gratitude, the door open and the relationship intact.

Back to the essays

Field Notes

A letter from Andrei Hasna on building with AI agents

Subscribe by email

By clicking “Subscribe”, I confirm that I want to get email delivered to my address and agree to Andrei Hasna’s Privacy Policy and Terms.

In each letter

  • New essays on AI agents and the systems behind them
  • What Hasna is building, and why
  • Costs, routing and results from real work
  • What did not work
  • News of the book and the podcast